Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore vs PPG: Paint Brand Comparison
Paint Brand Comparison
Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore vs PPG. Performance, durability, coverage, and cost analysis for professional commercial applications.
Sherwin-Williams
Industry-leading commercial paint with extensive product lines and nationwide availability
Benjamin Moore
Premium paint known for color richness, application quality, and architectural specifications
PPG Paints
Cost-effective commercial solutions with good performance and wide distribution
Detailed Brand Comparison
Side-by-side comparison of features, performance, and specifications.
Commercial Paint Brand Comparison
Comparison of Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, and PPG paint products
| Service Type | Coverage | Durability | Color Selection | VOC Options | Warranty | Availability | Price Tier | Specialty Lines | Price Range | Timeframe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sherwin-Williams Industry-leading commercial paint with extensive product lines and nationwide availability | Excellent (350-400 sq ft/gal) | Superior | 1,700+ colors | Zero-VOC available | Lifetime on premium lines | Nationwide | Mid to Premium | Extensive |
$35 - $
85
per gallon | Standard |
Benjamin Moore Premium paint known for color richness, application quality, and architectural specifications | Excellent (350-450 sq ft/gal) | Superior | 3,500+ colors | Zero-VOC available | Lifetime on premium lines | Good (independent dealers) | Premium | Moderate |
$45 - $
95
per gallon | Standard |
PPG Paints Cost-effective commercial solutions with good performance and wide distribution | Good (300-400 sq ft/gal) | Good to Very Good | 2,000+ colors | Low-VOC available | 25 years to Lifetime | Nationwide | Mid-range | Good |
$28 - $
68
per gallon | Faster dry times |
Sherwin-Williams
Industry-leading commercial paint with extensive product lines and nationwide availability
Features:
Price Range:
$35 - $ 85 per gallon
Best For:
- •High-traffic commercial spaces
- •Healthcare facilities
- •Food service environments
- •Properties needing maximum durability
- •Projects requiring specific VOC compliance
- •Multi-location portfolios
Pros:
- + Best coverage per gallon
- + Excellent durability and washability
- + Comprehensive commercial product line
- + Strong contractor support programs
- + Reliable nationwide availability
- + Advanced ColorSnap color matching
- + Eco-friendly options (Harmony, Emerald)
- + Proven track record in commercial
Cons:
- - Premium lines are expensive
- - Some products have longer dry times
- - Requires proper surface prep for warranty
- - Color consistency can vary by batch
Benjamin Moore
Premium paint known for color richness, application quality, and architectural specifications
Features:
Price Range:
$45 - $ 95 per gallon
Best For:
- •Premium commercial spaces
- •Architect-driven projects
- •Color-critical applications
- •Executive offices
- •Luxury retail
- •Historic preservation
Pros:
- + Richest, most accurate colors
- + Superior application and flow
- + Excellent hide and coverage
- + Architect-specified brand
- + Aura line has exceptional durability
- + Regal Select balances quality and price
- + Strong reputation for color fidelity
- + Low odor formulations
Cons:
- - Highest price point
- - Limited availability (not big box)
- - Fewer contractor programs
- - Smaller commercial-specific line
- - Longer lead times in some markets
PPG Paints
Cost-effective commercial solutions with good performance and wide distribution
Features:
Price Range:
$28 - $ 68 per gallon
Best For:
- •Budget-conscious projects
- •Large commercial portfolios
- •Industrial applications
- •Properties with frequent repainting
- •Value-engineered specifications
- •Quick-turn projects
Pros:
- + Best value for performance
- + Competitive pricing
- + Good coverage and hide
- + Wide distribution network
- + Speedhide line for commercial
- + Diamond line offers premium features
- + Strong industrial coating options
- + Faster dry times on many products
Cons:
- - Not quite the durability of SW or BM
- - Color selection more limited
- - Fewer zero-VOC options
- - Less name recognition
- - Application quality varies by line
Need Help Choosing the Right Service?
Our experts will assess your needs and recommend the best solution for your property.
Top Product Recommendations by Application
Standard Commercial Interior
Best balance of cost and performance for offices, retail, and general commercial spaces.
Premium Durability
Maximum durability for high-traffic areas, healthcare, and premium spaces.
Zero/Low-VOC
Environmentally friendly options for LEED projects and occupied spaces.
High-Traffic/Scuff-Resistant
Specialized formulations for schools, hospitals, and corridors.
Exterior Commercial
UV-resistant formulations for long-lasting exterior protection.
Industrial/Epoxy
Heavy-duty coatings for industrial floors, chemical resistance, and extreme environments.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which paint brand is best for commercial projects?
Sherwin-Williams is generally the best choice for most commercial projects due to their comprehensive commercial product line, excellent durability, nationwide availability, and strong contractor support. Their ProMar 200 is the industry standard for commercial interiors, while Duration and Emerald offer premium performance. Benjamin Moore is preferred for color-critical or architect-specified projects where color accuracy is paramount. PPG offers the best value for budget-conscious projects without sacrificing quality. We typically recommend Sherwin-Williams for 70% of commercial projects, Benjamin Moore for 20% (premium/luxury), and PPG for 10% (value-focused).
How do the costs compare between Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, and PPG?
PPG is the most cost-effective at $28-68 per gallon, making it 20-30% less expensive than competitors. Sherwin-Williams ranges $35-85 per gallon with mid-tier pricing but excellent coverage that reduces total gallons needed. Benjamin Moore is premium at $45-95 per gallon, commanding the highest prices but delivering superior color richness and application. When calculating total project cost, factor in coverage rates: Benjamin Moore Aura covers 400-450 sq ft/gallon, Sherwin-Williams Emerald covers 350-400 sq ft/gallon, and PPG Diamond covers 350-400 sq ft/gallon. Higher coverage can offset higher per-gallon costs.
Which brand has the best durability for high-traffic areas?
For high-traffic commercial areas, Sherwin-Williams Emerald and Benjamin Moore Aura tie for top durability, both offering exceptional scrubbability (100,000+ scrub cycles) and stain resistance. Sherwin-Williams Duration is also excellent and more cost-effective. For extreme durability needs (hospitals, schools, retail), Sherwin-Williams ProClassic or Benjamin Moore Scuff-X provide specialized scuff-resistant formulations. PPG's Diamond line offers good durability at a lower price point but doesn't match the premium lines of SW or BM. All three brands offer epoxy and urethane coatings for industrial applications where standard paint won't suffice.
Do you offer zero-VOC or low-VOC options from all brands?
Yes, all three brands offer low/zero-VOC options compliant with strict environmental regulations: Sherwin-Williams Harmony is their zero-VOC line with excellent performance, and Emerald is low-VOC with superior durability. Benjamin Moore's Natura is zero-VOC, while Aura and Regal Select are low-VOC. PPG offers Pure Performance as their zero-VOC option. For California CARB compliance or LEED projects, Sherwin-Williams has the most comprehensive documentation and widest range of compliant products. We can provide VOC data sheets and environmental certifications for any product specified. All zero-VOC lines perform nearly as well as their standard counterparts.
Which brand has the best color matching and selection?
Benjamin Moore leads in color with 3,500+ colors and the most accurate, rich pigments. Their colors are often architect-specified and have exceptional fidelity. Sherwin-Williams offers 1,700+ colors with excellent ColorSnap matching technology and consistent batch-to-batch color. PPG provides 2,000+ colors with good matching capabilities. For color-critical projects (branded environments, exact matches), Benjamin Moore is preferred. For most commercial applications, Sherwin-Williams' color range is sufficient and their matching system is highly accurate. All brands can match competitors' colors with 95%+ accuracy using spectrophotometer technology.
What warranties do these paint brands offer?
Sherwin-Williams offers lifetime warranties on premium lines (Emerald, Duration) and 25-year warranties on commercial lines (ProMar 200, SuperPaint). Benjamin Moore provides lifetime warranties on Aura and Regal Select. PPG offers 25-year to lifetime warranties depending on product line (Diamond has lifetime, Speedhide has 25-year). Warranties cover defects in product and premature failure under normal conditions. Important: All warranties require proper surface preparation and application per manufacturer specifications - improper prep voids warranty regardless of paint quality. We document all prep work to ensure warranty coverage. Labor warranties are provided by Moorhouse Coating separately from manufacturer product warranties.
Can you get contractor pricing on these brands?
Yes, we have established contractor accounts with all three brands providing significant savings: Sherwin-Williams offers the most robust contractor program with volume discounts, charge accounts, and job-site delivery. We typically see 30-40% off retail pricing. Benjamin Moore provides contractor pricing through their independent dealer network, usually 20-30% off retail. PPG offers competitive contractor programs with 25-35% discounts. These savings are passed directly to our clients. For large projects or multi-location portfolios, we can negotiate additional volume discounts. We also participate in loyalty programs that provide rebates and promotional pricing throughout the year.
Which brand do you recommend for different project types?
Our recommendations by project type: Office Buildings - Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200 (best value) or Duration (premium). Healthcare - Sherwin-Williams Harmony (zero-VOC, antimicrobial) or Benjamin Moore Natura. Retail - Sherwin-Williams Emerald (durability) or Benjamin Moore Scuff-X (scuff resistance). Industrial - Sherwin-Williams Macropoxy or PPG Amercoat (epoxy systems). Luxury/High-End - Benjamin Moore Aura (color richness). Budget-Conscious - PPG Speedhide or Diamond. Food Service - Sherwin-Williams ProClassic Waterborne (washability). Schools - Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200 Zero VOC or PPG Pure Performance. We provide specific product recommendations based on your performance requirements, budget, and environmental needs.
Need Help Selecting the Right Paint?
Our experts will recommend the optimal paint products based on your specific application, performance requirements, and budget.